November 2024 Decisions Roundup

In November 2024, the Information Commissioner received 3 new applications and closed 6 cases (2 withdrawn and 4 by decisions). As of 30 November 2024, public authorities’ compliance was pending for 6 of the Information Commissioner’s decisions.

Decision 32/2024, Bermuda Civil Aviation Authority

What was requested? Airport audit and inspection reports and other documentation by the Authority’s technical officers.

What was the outcome? In her Decision, the Information Commissioner affirmed the Authority’s decision to administratively deny the PATI request, in full, because she agreed that processing the request would have created a substantial and unreasonable interference with or disruption to the Authority’s other work. The parties had been unable to agree on a reasonably narrowed request scope, which would have allowed the Authority to continue processing the request. The Information Commissioner did not require the Authority to take any further action.

Decision 33/2024, Information and Digital Technologies Department

Decision 34/2024, Ministry of Health Headquarters

What was requested? The Information Commissioner assessed two public authorities’ decisions on separate PATI requests seeking records on the same topic. The Applicant asked for all records about tech companies BPMS, InnoFund and i3 and Fastpass, a port-of-entry system project.

What was the outcome? The Information Commissioner was not persuaded by either public authority’s reliance on the exemption about prejudice to a trial or adjudication. However, after applying the personal information exemption to the sets of remaining records in both reviews, the Information Commissioner did partially uphold each authority’s decision. She found that the Information & Digital Technologies Department was justified, in part, in relying on an exemption to protect public authorities’ deliberative information from public disclosure. She found that the Ministry of Health Headquarters was justified, in part, in relying on an exemption to prevent public disclosure of information that could have prejudiced negotiations. Both have been ordered to disclose certain records by 15 January 2025.

Decision 35/2024, The Cabinet Office Headquarters

What was requested? Records about government spending on a specific PATI request and PATI consultants.

What was the outcome? The Information Commissioner found that the Cabinet Office Headquarters had not issued an internal review decision to the Applicant within the 6-week timeline set out in the PATI Act. The Cabinet Office Headquarters was ordered to issue its internal review decision by 3 January 2025.

As at 30 November 2024, the Information Commissioner had:

Total applications: 348

Pending investigations: 33

Applications pending validation: 1

Closed reviews – decided: 222

Closed applications – resolved (settled): 51

Closed applications – invalid: 34

Closed applications – abandoned: 7

Decisions pending compliance: 6

Information Commissioner’s Decision (or other request) subject to judicial review: 0